What happens if bitcoin succeeds?
26 February 2021

As the price of bitcoin continues to rise, this column argues that most of us would not want to live in a society where bitcoin succeeds. Fortunately, the internal contradictions and perverse consequences of cryptocurrencies success mean that they are destined for failure. Until then, it might make sense for speculators to ride the cryptocurrency bubble, so long as they get out in time.

More

Global market risk
15 February 2021

There are a million ways to measure financial risk, and if one wants to calculate global risk, it requires a truly heroic set of assumptions. But it’s much easier to calculate global market risk, and that is what I set myself to do below.

More

On the future of Amazon
13 February 2021

As Amazon continues its exponential growth, where will it all end? Growth has to stop, but when and why?

More

How fast is the Apple M1?
8 February 2021

The new Apple M1 processor has gotten excellent reviews for speed. Getting curious, I measured its speed on pure c code, latex and R and compared it to its most recent Intel competitors.

More

Moral hazard, the fear of the markets, and how central banks responded to Covid-19
28 January 2021

While the direct economic consequences of Covid-19 have been significant, the impact on the financial markets has been more nuanced. This column uses a unique data set on the financial markets’ fears and perceptions of long-run financial risk to identify how Covid-19, and particularly Fed policy responses to Covid-19, affected global market fears. While some Fed interventions had little or no impact on market fear, the most powerful were the US dollar swap lines, which strongly reduced the perceived likelihood of global market losses decades into the future. The results suggest that the Fed’s relative global role has been strengthened, possibly at the cost of increased moral hazard.

More

Central bank digital currencies
13 January 2021

Central-bank digital currencies will make the financial system more efficient. But will they make it safer? Maybe, but they could easily end up increasing systemic risk. Depends on the implementation.

More

Erasmus and Turing
11 January 2021

As a part of its quest for independence, Britain decided to leave the Erasmus program. We now have Turing, the global version. So, will it lead us to the sunny uplands?

More

Brexit and Marxism
3 January 2021

The Brexiteers and Karl Marx have more in common than often thought. Both were guided by ideology, and both refused to tell us how to get to the sunny uplands they promised.

More

What to do about the Covid financial system bailouts?
22 December 2020

Financial crises and bailouts of financial institutions are inevitable and can’t be prevented without paying too high a price. Diversity is the best way to minimise the frequency and severity of crises and ensure sustainable high economic growth.

More

The crypto-technical response to the Covid-19 bailouts
13 December 2020

Are cryptocurrencies and blockchains the solution to the problem laid bare by the Covid-19 bailout of the financial system? No.

More

The libertarian response to the Covid-19 financial turmoil
9 December 2020

A libertarian sees the Covid-19 bailout of the financial system as a predictable failure of regulations. Much better to have a laissez-faire economy and never, ever bail private firms out. But does the laissez-faire utopia survive contact with reality?

More

The socialist response to the Covid-19 financial turmoil
4 December 2020

The state just saved the financial system from itself. What is the point of privately owned banks if they need to be bailed out every decade?

More

On the response of the financial authorities to Covid-19
2 December 2020

The financial authorities have just bailed the financial system out for the second time in a decade. While the authorities are proud of having prevented a financial crisis, are we really better off? No, one cannot judge the policy intervention a success if it is only due to the promise of the intervention that the problem arose in the first place.

More

The Covid-19 bailouts and the future of the capitalist banking system
26 November 2020

The central banks bailed out the financial system in March 2020, the second time they have done so in 12 years. What is the point of privately owned banks if they require a bailout every decade?

More

Which programming language is best for economic research: Julia, Matlab, Python or R?
20 August 2020

The most widely used programming languages for economic research are Julia, Matlab, Python and R. This column uses three criteria to compare the languages: the power of available libraries, the speed and possibilities when handling large datasets, and the speed and ease-of-use for a computationally intensive task. While R is still a good choice, Julia is the language the authors now tend to pick for new projects and generally recommend.

More

ARM on AWS for R
15 June 2020

Amazon AWS has been recommending ARM Graviton2 as a cost-effective alternative to Intel/AMD instances. So I tried it out.

More

Low vol strategies
8 May 2020

Does it make sense to invest in low vol funds?

More

Of Julia and R
8 May 2020

I just tried the same code in R’s data.tables and Julia’s DataFrames, and the results are a bit surprising.

More

How to manipulate risk forecasts 101
30 April 2020

It is easy to manipulate risk forecasts. If your regulator or compliance officer sets a risk target you don’t like, just tell them what they want to hear and continue taking the risk you like.

More

The five principles of correct riskometer use
27 April 2020

It is easy to criticise risk forecasting, but it’s rather pointless unless one can come up with proposals. Here are my five principles for the correct use of riskometers.

More

The problem with Backtesting
25 April 2020

Backtesting is the magical technique that tells us how well a forecast model works. Test the model on history, and we have an objective way to evaluate how good the model is. But does it really work in practice?

More

The magic of riskometers
24 April 2020

The way financial risk is measured is by a device I have called the riskometer. It is a fantastic thing, plunge it into the bowels of the City of London and out pops a single accurate measurement of risk. Magical. But does it work in practice?

More

Risk and scientific socialism
23 April 2020

The way we manage financial risk has a lot in common with the old concept of scientific socialism. The modern-day riskometer is pseudoscientific, and the increased reliance on it leads to disastrous systemic risk.

More

Financial crises and epidemics
19 April 2020

Epidemics and financial crises are different beasts. But they are eerily similar underneath — The dynamics, the politics, the mistakes and the learning all are the same.

More

Hayek and Corona
17 April 2020

Corona is unprecedented and I am willing to give government’s plenty of latitude. Mistakes will be made. But some are worse than others, and the dumbest economic mistake I have seen comes out of France this week. Friedrich Hayek saw it coming in 1944.

More

Hayek et Corona
17 April 2020

Corona est sans précédent et je suis enclin à permettre aux gouvernements une grande latitude. Des erreurs seront commises. Mais certaines sont pires que d’autres, et l’erreur économique la plus stupide que j’ai vue a été commise par la France cette semaine. Friedrich Hayek l’avait prévu en 1944.

More

Ignoring the Corona analysis
15 April 2020

We are bombarded by Corona epidemiology analysis. How it spreads, how to contain it, how to cure it, how it will play out. I am ignoring it all.

More

The coronavirus crisis is no 2008
26 March 2020

Many comparisons have been made between the coronavirus crisis and the global systemic crisis in 2008. This column argues that seen through the lens of exogenous and endogenous risk, these two crises are quite different. Coronavirus is unlikely to cause a global systemic crisis, and the policy response should be different.

More

Artificial intelligence as a central banker
6 March 2020

Artificial intelligence, such as the Bank of England Bot, is set to take over an increasing number of central bank functions. This column argues that the increased use of AI in central banking will bring significant cost and efficiency benefits, but also raise important concerns that are so far unresolved.

More

Systemic consequences of outsourcing to the cloud
2 December 2019

Financial institutions are increasingly outsourcing information technology to the cloud, motivated by efficiency, security, and cost. This column argues that the consequence is likely to be short- and medium-term stability at the cost of the increased likelihood of catastrophic systemic events. Cloud providers are systemically important and should be regulated as such.

More

The dissonance of the short and long term
12 August 2019

The type of risk we most care about is long-term, what happens over years or decades, but we tend to manage that risk over short periods. This column argues that the dissonance of risk is that we measure and manage what we don’t care about and ignore what we do.

More

Central banks and reputation risk
6 August 2019

As central banks accumulate ever more job functions, their reputation risk increases. This column offers a cautionary tale from Iceland where, after the central bank was put in charge of capital controls, it was subject to severe attacks because of perceived mistakes in how the capital controls were enforced. The accumulation of powers erodes a central bank’s independence and subjects it to regulatory paralysis.

More

The Brexit culture war
5 May 2019

In all the disappointments about Brexit, one stands out for me — the inability of the libertarian Brexiteers to outline a coherent vision of what Brexit will accomplish. They used to see rational economic management as as a virtue, now what matters is culture.

Brexit discussions have degenerated into a culture war.

More

All about BoB — The Bank of England Bot
29 April 2019

Imagine the day when BoB — the Bank of England bot — comes to life, the artificial intelligence engine designed to keep us safe from the evils of the financial system.

More

My tiny, tiny contribution to Apple's fall in profits
6 January 2019

Apple’s revenues are falling. A tiny, tiny part is thanks to me. Why? I used to buy a new Apple device every six months, but no more.

More

The 2018 market in a 250 year context
1 January 2019

The financial markets did not have a good 2018 as the media kept on reminding us:

More

Short and long-term risk
3 December 2018

The riskiest year in human history was 1962. The year of the Cuban missile crisis, the closest we ever came to a nuclear war. The mother of all tail events, where all prices go to zero. Volatility that year was average — 16.5%

How can market risk be average when tail risk is at its highest?

More

Perceived and actual risk
2 December 2018

Perceived risk is risk predicted by models and actual risk is the fundamental underlying risk. We measure perceived risk and care about actual risk. Unfortunately, those two are negatively correlated.

More

Cryptocurrencies: Financial stability and fairness
9 November 2018

If private cryptocurrencies were to find widespread economic use the result would be increased financial instability, inequality, and social instability.

More

The October 2018 stock market in a historical context
1 November 2018

Was last month’s stock market crash was as bad as some are making out?

More

The hierarchy of financial policies
12 September 2018

On top is the authority in charge of fiscal policy, followed by those running monetary, microprudential, and finally macroprudential policies. This ranking can cause conflicts in terms of policy effectiveness and legitimacy.

More

Which numerical computing language is best: Julia, MATLAB, Python or R?
9 July 2018

More

Cryptocurrencies
26 June 2018

Are cryptocurrencies the future of money, Ponzi schemes, speculators dream, freedom or just a cult?

More

What are risk models good for?
3 June 2018

One can endlessly criticise risk models, but that is just too nihilistic. So, what are the good for? There are three camps, the model believers, the rejectionists and the healthy skeptics. I’m going to make the case for the last below.

More

The McNamara fallacy in financial policymaking
1 June 2018

One of the puzzling things about post-crisis financial policymaking is the dual understanding that we missed the excessive build-up of risk before 2007 in spite of having all the numbers right in front of us and at the same time founding the new world order on numbers and measurements. Have the policymakers fallen for the McNamara fallacy?

More

VIX, CISS and all the political uncertainty
20 May 2018

Two widely used indicators of financial risk, the VIX index and the ECB’s CISS, are at a historical low. The (financial) world must be really safe. However, that doesn’t square with all the newspaper headlines screaming political uncertainty. What gives?

More

Here be dragons
30 March 2018

Medieval mapmakers noted the risk of an unknown kind by “here be dragons”. Attempts at measuring extreme risk should come with a similar warning. Just like the sailors of yesteryear, financial institutions will go into unknown territories and, just like the map makers of the earlier era, modern risk modellers have little to say.

More

Low risk as a predictor of financial crises
26 March 2018

Reliable indicators of future financial crises are important for policymakers and practitioners. While most indicators consider an observation of high volatility as a warning signal, this column argues that such an alarm comes too late, arriving only once a crisis is already under way. A better warning is provided by low volatility, which is a reliable indication of an increased likelihood of a future crisis.

More

Cryptocurrencies don't make sense
13 February 2018

Cryptocurrencies are supposedly a new and superior form of money and investments – the way of the future. The author of this column, however, does not see the point of cryptocurrencies, finding them no better than existing fiat money or good investments.

More

Yesterday's mini crash in a historical context
6 February 2018

The stock market had a mini crash yesterday. So how big was that in a historical context?

More

Artificial intelligence and the stability of markets
15 November 2017

Artificial intelligence is increasingly used to tackle all sorts of problems facing people and societies. This column considers the potential benefits and risks of employing AI in financial markets. While it may well revolutionise risk management and financial supervision, it also threatens to destabilise markets and increase systemic risk.

More

European bank-sovereign doom loop
30 September 2017

European banks and sovereigns are much more closely linked than American banks and their government. The resulting bank-sovereign doom loop has been gathering strength, since the 2008 crisis.

More

Do the new financial regulations favour the largest banks?
27 September 2017

The new postcrisis financial regulations, for example Basel III, have the unfortunate side effect of favouring the largest banks relative to the smaller. This can result in concentration, oligopolies, and even larger SIFI banks. This problem is made worse because of how Europe likes to regulate.

More

The ECB Systemic Risk Indicator
24 September 2017

The European Central Bank has an indicator of systemic risk called the Composite Indicator of Systemic Stress , CISS. So what sort of signal does it send and what is it to be used for?

More

Finance is not engineering
22 September 2017

Regulations change behaviour and outcomes. It is seductively attractive to say that someone misbehaves, therefore we need the rule to prevent the misbehaviour. However, human beings, being human, don’t just comply, their behaviour changes. That is why regulating the financial system is infinitely more complex than engineering.

More

University of Iceland seminar
14 June 2017

I did a seminar at the University of Iceland. The first half of the presentation was about risk and regulations and the second part is about economic policy in Iceland. The slides can be downloaded from here.

The announcement is here.

The slides are in English but the Icelandic title is:

Stenst uppskriftin í raunverulegum bakstri? Getur þjóðhagsvarúð og peningastefna skilað því sem lofað er - eða aðeins lækka hagvöxt að nauðsynjalausu?

More

Brexit and systemic risk
31 May 2017

Brexit is likely to cause considerable disruption for financial markets. Some worry that it may also increase systemic risk. This column revisits the debate and argues that an increase in systemic risk is unlikely. While legal ‘plumbing’ and institutional and regulatory equivalence are of concern, systemic risk is more likely to fall due to increased financial fragmentation and caution by market participants in the face of uncertainty.

More

Should macroprudential policy target real estate prices?
12 May 2017

Keynote speech at the bank of Lithuania on “Should macroprudential policy target real estate prices?”

The slides can be downloaded here and the presentation can be seen here.

More

Is Julia ready for prime time?
12 March 2017

March 2017

I really want to like Julia. She promises to solve all the frustrations with other numerical languages.

More

With capital controls gone, Iceland must prioritise investing abroad
12 March 2017

The Icelandic government announced today it it lifting its capital controls. Private investors, pension funds and the government need to prioritise investing abroad to lower the chance of another crash.

The Icelandic authorities in November 2008 imposed capital controls because they were in a panic over how to react to the crisis. The IMF was an enthusiastic supporter, its representative at the time arguing that it was one half of a belts and suspenders policy, the other being interest rates of 21%.

More

Competing Brexit visions
25 February 2017

I have been struggling to make sense of the Brexit debate. Perfectly reasonable, well informed and highly intelligent people reach diametrically opposite conclusions, all impeccably argued. In order to make sense of the debate, I did what any quant might do and made a graph of the competing Brexit visions.

More

Systemic consequences of Brexit
23 February 2017

I got to present on the systemic risk consequences of Brexit in a SUERF conference. The slides can be downloaded here. The main conclusions are:

More

Why macropru can end up being procyclical
15 December 2016

Discretionary macroprudential policies aim to be countercyclical by adjusting risk-taking across the financial cycle. This column argues that the opposite effect may happen in certain cases. Depending on how regulators measure risk and how they react, the eventual outcome may well be procyclical, with serious unintended consequences.

More

The fatal flaw in macropru: It ignores political risk
8 December 2016

Political risk is a major cause of systemic financial risk. This column argues that both the integrity and the legitimacy of macroprudential policy, or ‘macropru’, depends on political risk being included with other risk factors. Yet it is usually excluded from macropru, and that could be a fatal flaw.

More

Why it doesn't make sense to hold bonds
27 June 2016

Investor demand for bonds is very high. This column argues that this is surprising because under almost any likely inflation scenario, including central banks merely hitting their target inflation rates, bondholders suffer large losses. The beneficiaries are sovereign and corporate borrowers; the losers are pension funds, insurance companies and some foreign exchange reserve funds. Meanwhile, the systemic risk from a bond crisis is increasing.

More

On the financial market consequences of Brexit
24 June 2016

Brexit creates new opportunities and new risks for the British and EU financial markets. Both could benefit, but a more likely outcome is a fall in the quality of financial regulations, more inefficiency, more protectionism, and more systemic risk.

More

Cyber risk as systemic risk
10 June 2016

The threat to the financial system posed by cyber risk is often claimed to be systemic. This column argues against this, pointing out that almost all cyber risk is microprudential. For a cyber attack to lead to a systemic crisis, it would need to be timed impeccably to coincide with other non-cyber events that undermine confidence in the financial system and the authorities. The only actors with enough resources to affect such an event are large sovereign states, and they could likely create the required uncertainty through simpler, financial means.

More

Big Banks' Risk Does Not Compute
24 May 2016

A Bloomberg piece that cites our work, Big Banks’ Risk Does Not Compute.

More

Interview on þjóðbraut on Hringbraut
21 May 2016

I was interviewed on the new programme þjóðbraut on the Icelandic TV station Hringbraut. Only if you speak Icelandic.

More

Farewell CoCos
26 April 2016

One can only welcome ECB’s rethinking on CoCos. They make banks’ capital structures unnecessarily complicated and create hidden risks.

More

Will Brexit give us the 1950s or Hong Kong?
18 April 2016

At the risk of overgeneralising, Brexiteers have two, rather different world views — 1950s Britain or the hip, modern, perhaps like Hong Kong. One certainly is more likely.

More

Of Brexit and regulations
16 April 2016

One often hears from Brexit supporters that too many regulations come from Brussels, that it would be much better if we could regulate ourselves. At least when it comes to finance, that argument just does not hold water.

More

IMF and Iceland
12 April 2016

I just spotted an interview with the IMF representatives to Iceland about their policy prescriptions, and it did make for an interesting reading.

More

Stability in Iceland
7 April 2016

I got to address the annual meeting of Business Iceland today on the topic of “On fiscal and monetary policy in Iceland”. The main theme was about what to do about the high economic volatility.

More

Everybody right, everybody wrong: Plural rationalities in macroprudential regulation
18 March 2016

Macroprudential policy has become increasingly popular in the aftermath of the Global Crisis, but it remains controversial. This column argues that vigorous disagreement is both inevitable and healthy, reflecting differing fundamental views of how the financial system really works. By embracing the divergence of views instead of seeing it as problematic, macroprudential policymaking will be made easier and more effective. åÊ

More

Of tail risk
12 March 2016

Suppose one cares about tail risk, what is the best way to estimate it? There are two, not mutually exclusive, ways; statistical and structural. Which is right?

More

Models and regulations and the political leadership
26 February 2016

Why do the regulatory authorities seemingly fall into the category of model believers, if not quite to the view that there must be one true model? Well, it is sort of inevitable the way the regulatory process works.

More

Why do we rely so much on models when we know they can't be trusted?
25 February 2016

There a lot of evidence that models are less than perfectly reliable. Why then do we rely so much on models in decision-making, and especially financial regulations? Because there are three types of people: Believers in true model, skeptics who accept model risk and nihilistic rejectionists.

More

Does a true model exist and does it matter?
25 February 2016

When designing models, the underlying assumption is often that the model captures the true data generating process. Does a true model exist? To me, the question is completely irrelevant.

More

The point of central banks
25 January 2016

Much of the analysis of the recent market turmoil is amusing. Take the Wall Street Journal, Why the Fed Is the Root of Much Market Turmoil: Fed is a key reason markets have plunged and risk of recession rising . Here is a quote:

More

The macro-micro conflict
20 October 2015

There has always been conflict between macro- and microeconomic regulation. Microeconomic policy reigns supreme during good times, and macro during bad. This column explains that while the macro and micro objectives have always been present in regulatory design, their relative importance has varied according to the changing requirements of economic, financial and political cycles. The conflict between the two seems set to deepen and so, regardless of which wins, policymakers must not undermine the central bank’s execution of monetary policy.

More

Volatility, financial crises and Minsky's hypothesis
2 October 2015

More

Impact of the recent market turmoil on risk measures
28 August 2015

Last January I looked at how the Swiss FX shock affected the most popular risk measures. Events of the past week give us another interesting test. My daily risk forecast shows the various risk measures for a number of assets, but focus on the SP-500, and the following picture taken from the site today:

More

Iceland, Greece and political hectoring
13 August 2015

The Greek and the Icelandic crisis have much in common, not the least the heavy pressure from foreign countries and the hectoring from their public officials. In Iceland and in Greece this was counterproductive, hardening the opposition to any settlement. The will to reform needs to come from within, and the sooner the Troika realizes this, the easier it will be to deal with the Greek situation.

More

A proposed research and policy agenda for systemic risk
7 August 2015

The long-running Greek crisis and China’s recent stock market crash are the latest threats to the stability of the global financial system. But as this column explains, systemic risk is an inevitable part of any market-based economy. While we won’t eliminate systemic risk entirely, the agenda for researchers and policymakers should be to create a more resilient financial system that is less prone to disastrous crises and that still delivers benefits for the economy and for society.

More

Are asset managers systemically important?
5 August 2015

Some financial authorities have proposed designating asset managers as systemically important financial institutions (SIFIs). This column argues that this would be premature and probably ill conceived. The motivation for such a step comes from an inappropriate application of macroprudential thought from banking, rather than the underlying externalities that might cause asset managers to contribute to systemic risk. Further, policy authorities are silent on the question of what SIFI designation should mean in practice, despite the inherent link between identification and remedy.

More

Objective function of macro-prudential regulations
24 July 2015

I have been in a conference for the past few days, and have seen a few presentations on macropru type regulations.

More

Risky business: Finding the balance between financial stability and risk
24 July 2015

Our LSE blog It is important that we understand and do something about systemic risk. The problem is that we desire two incompatible things simultaneously: we wish the financial system to be safe; but we also want to finance risky economic activity.

More

Regulators could be responsible for next financial crash
21 July 2015

LSE report warns that forcing financial institutions to forecast risk in the same way could mean they will all end up being caught unawares.
A writeup in the Telegraph about our Magazine.

More

How Iceland is falling behind. On Sprengisandur
12 July 2015

I got to be on the radio show Sprengisandur, if you understand Icelandic. After discussing Greece, got asked about Iceland. The Icelandic authorities could have made some of the same mistakes as the Greek government did in its crisis, but overall, the three governments since then, have done a decent job. All, in their own way, paving the way for prosperity.

More

Greece on Sprengisandur
12 July 2015

I got to talk about Greece on the radio show Sprengisandur, if you understand Icelandic.

More

Why Iceland can now remove capital controls
11 June 2015

Iceland has just announced it is getting rid of its capital controls. This column argues that the government’s plan is a credible, efficient and fair plan to lift the costly and misguided controls.

More

Market moves that are supposed to happen every half-decade keep happening
14 May 2015

May 14, 2015
Bloomberg today had an interesting piece, called Market Moves That Are Supposed to Happen Every Half-Decade Keep Happening. Here is their self-described “terribly simplistic list”

More

Capital controls
12 May 2015

May 12, 2015
I got to participate in a discussion on capital controls, sponsored by Samtök Atvinnulífsins which could be translated as the Icelandic Chamber of Commerce. The event was held in the lovely Harpa. If you read Icelandic, the writeup is here with my slides.

More

What do ES and VaR say about the tails
25 April 2015

So, does ES capture tail risk, but VaR not? Therefore the Basel committee is correct, and we all should use ES. Is that true?

More

Why risk is hard to measure
25 April 2015

Regulators and financial institutions increasingly depend on statistical risk forecasting. This column argues that most risk modelling approaches are highly inaccurate and confidence intervals should be provided along with point estimates. Two major approaches, value-at-risk and expected shortfall are compared, and while the former is found to be superior in practice, it is also easier to be manipulated by forecasters.åÊ

More

Post-Crisis banking regulation: Evolution of economic thinking as it happened on Vox
2 March 2015

This column introduces a new Vox eBook collecting some of the best Vox columns on financial regulations, starting with the fundamentals of financial regulations, moving on to bank capital and the Basel regulations, and finishing with the wider considerations of the regulatory agenda and the political dimension. Collecting columns from over the past six years, this eBook maps the evolution of leading thought on banking regulation.

More

The Danish FX event
24 February 2015

Denmark had a small FX event on March 20, in the context of the Swiss FX shock, it is not much a of an event, but it does reinforce stereotypes.

More

On the Swiss FX shock
24 February 2015

Just looked again at the what I did on the Swiss FX shock, looking at how the various risk measures performed in the days after the event, and also looking at the risk of the inverse FX.

The original analysis just looked at the risk of the Franc appreciating, but why not look at the risk of the euro appreciating.

More

Europe's proposed capital markets union
23 February 2015

The proposed EU capital markets union aims to revitalise Europe’s economy by creating efficient funding channels between providers of loanable funds and firms best placed to use them. This column argues that a successful union would deliver investment, innovation, and growth, but it depends on overcoming difficult regulatory challenges. A successful union would also change the nature of systemic risk in Europe.

More

What the Swiss FX shock says about risk models
18 January 2015

The Swiss central bank last week abandoned its euro exchange rate ceiling. This column argues that the fallout from the decision demonstrates the inherent weaknesses of the regulator-approved standard risk models used in financial institutions. These models under-forecast risk before the announcement and over-forecast risk after the announcement, getting it wrong in all states of the world.

More

Model risk: Risk measures when models may be wrong
8 June 2014

Risk forecasting is central to financial regulations, risk management, and macroprudential policy. This column raises concerns about the reliance on risk forecasting, since risk forecast models have high levels of model risk - especially when the models are needed the most, during crises. Policymakers should be wary of relying solely on such models. Formal model-risk analysis should be a part of the regulatory design process.

More

The new market-risk regulations
28 November 2013

Basel III is coming into focus. The fundamental logic of the regulatory changes seems sensible, but the devil is in the detail - empirical implementation. This column discusses a detailed quantitative study, incorporating analytical calculations, Monte Carlo simulations and results from observed data. It concludes that the Basel Committee has taken three and a half steps backwards and half a step forward. If implemented, the framework is likely to lead to less robust risk forecasts than current methodologies.

More

Solvency II: Three principles to respect
21 October 2013

Europe is set to finally approve new insurance regulation, Solvency II. This column argues that the final text should respect three fundamental principles to ensure solvency.

More

Political challenges of the macroprudential agenda
6 September 2013

Central banks frequently lead the macroprudential policy implementation. The hope is that their credibility in conquering inflation might rub off on macroprudential policy. This column argues the opposite. The fuzziness of the macroprudential agenda and the interplay of political pressures may undermine monetary policy.

More

Iceland's post-Crisis economy: A myth or a miracle?
21 May 2013

Icelandic voters recently ejected its post-Crisis government - a government that successfully avoided economic collapse when the odds were stacked against it. The new government comprises the same parties that were originally responsible for the Crisis. What’s going on? This column argues that this switch is, in fact, logical given the outgoing government’s mishandling of the economy and their deference towards foreign creditors.

More

The capital controls in Cyprus and the Icelandic experience
28 March 2013

Cyprus has imposed temporary capital controls. This column sheds light on how temporary and how damaging they are likely to be, based on Iceland’s experience. The longer controls exist, the harder they are to abolish. Icelandic capital controls, which have been ‰Û÷temporary’ for half a decade, deeply damage the economy by discouraging investment. We can only hope the authorities that created the chaos in the first place realise that temporary really needs to mean temporary.

More

Towards a more procyclical financial system
6 March 2013

Is the fact that different banks have different risk models problematic? Contrary to the Basel Committee and the European Banking Authority, this column argues that heterogeneity is a good thing. It leads to countercyclicality, and thereby reduces instances of procyclical price movements. Both the Basel Committee and the European Banking Authority have indicated that they are troubled by heterogeneity and are seeking to rectify the problem. Their conclusion is plainly wrong.

More

Europe's pre-Eurozone debt crisis: Faroe Islands in the 1990s
11 September 2012

The current EZ crisis is not Europe’s first sovereign-debt crisis. This column shows parallels can be drawn from an all-but-forgotten episode, i.e. the 1990 Faroese crisis. Just like Greece, the Faroes got into difficulty because of excess borrowing facilitated by a currency union with an AAA-rated partner undeterred as the sovereign debt spiralled upwards. In the Faroese case, the crisis was eventually resolved when political necessities outweighed the cost of the bailout.

More

Countercyclical regulation in Solvency II: Merits and flaws
23 June 2012

October 2011 saw the latest draft of Solvency II, the European Union’s code for regulation of the insurance industry. This column argues that the latest proposals need to be drafted again, urgently.

More

The Greek crisis: When political desire triumphs economic reality
2 March 2012

October 2011 saw the latest draft of Solvency II, the European Union’s code for regulation of the insurance industry. This column argues that the latest proposals need to be drafted again, urgently.

More

Iceland and the IMF: Why the capital controls are entirely wrong
14 November 2011

The IMF has emerged from the global crisis bigger and more powerful. But this column argues that the capital controls it required Iceland to adopt in 2008 are not of the soft and cuddly modern type that slow hot money flows. Instead they are akin to the draconian controls common in the 1950s. They violate the civil rights of Icelanders and significantly hamper economic growth.

More

Iceland: Was the IMF programme successful?
27 October 2011

According to the IMF, Iceland has graduated from its Fund-supported programme with unqualified success. This column begs to differ.

More

How not to resolve a banking crisis: Learning from Iceland's mistakes
26 October 2011

Much of macroeconomic policymaking is trial and error. This column discusses calamitous error on the part of Iceland’s policymakers, in the hope that others can at least try something else.

More

Capital, politics and bank weaknesses
27 June 2011

A debate is raging on capital adequacy requirements for banks. The UK wants to be allowed to be on ‰ÛÏtop up‰Û the agreed levels, i.e. to impose stricter capital standards than the EU minimum. This column argues the UK is right, and that the German and French opposition might be motivated by weaknesses in their banking systems.

More

The appropriate use of risk models: Part II
17 June 2011

Financial risk models have been widely criticised for both theoretical and practical failures, especially during the recent financial crisis. In the second of two columns, the authors outline why the shortcomings of risk models matter before making suggestions for how the financial industry and supervisors should use models in practice.

More

The appropriate use of risk models: Part I
16 June 2011

Risk models are at the heart of the financial sector’s self-monitoring as well as supervision by regulators. This column, the first of two, addresses the question of how risk models are misused in practice by practitioners and supervisors alike. This misuse causes risk management to fail when it is most needed.

More

Lessons from the Icesave rejection
27 April 2011

Icelanders have voted against providing a government guarantee for claims made by the UK and the Dutch governments against Iceland’s deposit insurance fund. This column argues that the heated debates surrounding the referendum may provide a glimpse into the challenges that lie ahead for European policymakers as they attempt to allocate losses suffered by banks between the taxpayers of different countries.

More

A prudential regulatory issue at the heart of Solvency II
31 March 2011

A delicate regulatory question is under consideration on the capital (reserve) requirements at the heart of Solvency II (the insurance industry equivalent of Basel III), which is scheduled to come into effect by 2013. This decision will have implications for both regulation of insurers and for macroprudential stability. The six authors of this article were invited to discuss the issues and concluded that more public scrutiny over this important question is urgently needed.

More

Valuing insurers' liabilities during crises: What EU policymakers should not do
18 March 2011

In crises, insurance companies’ asset values may fall significantly without a corresponding drop in their liabilities. European insurers have argued that their liabilities should be discounted by a higher rate during crises, lest regulations force them to raise more capital at exactly the wrong time. This column argues that that would be the wrong approach to the problem.

More

Risk and crises: How the models failed and are failing
18 February 2011

Financial models are widely blamed for underestimating and thus mispricing risk prior to the crisis. This column analyses how the models failed and questions their prominent use in the post-crisis reform process. It argues that over-relying on market data and statistical forecasting models has the potential to further destabilise the financial system and increase systemic risk.

More

The saga of Icesave: A new CEPR Policy Insight
26 January 2010

Icelanders may well reject the terms of the financial deal with Britain and the Dutch in a March referendum. This column introduces a new CEPR Policy Insight arguing that responsibility for Icesave losses falls jointly on Iceland, Britain and the Netherlands. Regardless of the vote, the three governments should come to a more reasonable agreement that enables Iceland to pay its obligations without tipping the economy into the abyss.

More

Iceland applies for EU membership, the outcome is uncertain
21 July 2009

The Icelandic parliament has decided to apply for EU membership. This column warns that domestic opposition and outstanding disputes with EU member countries on Icesave may derail the agreement.

More

Bonus incensed
25 May 2009

Bank bonuses have been blamed for contributing to the crisis, and regulators and politicians are now demanding changes in compensation arrangements. Most of these calls are based on a misconception of the nature of financial risk, an inflated view of the efficacy of risk models, and an incorrect view of the incentive issues facing financial institutions. This column proposes reforms that would discipline senior managers by exposing them to the dangers of junior managers’ risk taking.

More

Not so fast! There's no reason to regulate everything
25 March 2009

Many are calling for significant new financial regulations. This column says that if the regulate everything that moves crowd has its way, we will repeat past mistakes and impose significant costs on the economy, to little or no benefit. The next crisis is years away, we have time to do bank regulation right.

More

Modelling financial turmoil through endogenous risk
11 March 2009

By incorporating endogenous risk into a standard asset-pricing model, this column shows how banks’ capacity to bear risk seemingly evaporates in the face of market turmoil, pushing the financial system further into a tailspin. It suggests that risk-sensitive prudential regulation, in the spirit of Basel II, makes systemic financial crises sharper, larger, and more costly.

More

Financial regulation built on sand: The myth of the riskometer
1 March 2009

Much of today’s financial regulation assumes that risk can be accurately measured so that financial engineers, like civil engineers, can design safe products with sophisticated maths informed by historical estimates. But, as the crisis has shown, the laws of finance react to financial engineers’ creations, rendering risk calculations invalid. Regulators should rely on simpler methods.

More

Government failures in Iceland: Entranced by banking
9 February 2009

Some view Iceland’s crisis as holding lessons for any country with an outsized financial sector, e.g. the UK. This column disagrees, arguing that Iceland’s downfall is explained by the way its unique history, inappropriate policy responses, and weaknesses in EU banking regulations created a perfect storm, unlikely to happen elsewhere.

More

How bad could the crisis get? Lessons from Iceland
12 November 2008

Iceland’s banking system is ruined. GDP is down 65% in euro terms. Many companies face bankruptcy; others think of moving abroad. A third of the population is considering emigration. The British and Dutch governments demand compensation, amounting to over 100% of Icelandic GDP, for their citizens who held high-interest deposits in local branches of Icelandic banks. Europe’s leaders urgently need to take step to prevent similar things from happening to small nations with big banking sectors.

More

Regulation and financial models: Complexity kills
29 September 2008

Complex financial models and intricate assets structures meant extraordinary profits before the crisis. Markets for structured products became overly inflated as even the banks did not have a clear view of the state of their investments. Given complexity’s role in today’s mess, future regulation should focus on variables that are easy to measure and hard to manipulate (e.g. leverage ratios).

More

Blame the models
8 May 2008

In response to financial turmoil, supervisors are demanding more risk calculations. But model-driven mispricing produced the crisis, and risk models don’t perform during crisis conditions. The belief that a really complicated statistical model must be right is merely foolish sophistication.

More

3.6

2021-02-05

9.2

Maximum in 2020

9.3

Maximum in 2008
Annual maxima of daily risk