Models
30 posts in this category
How data lies
22 July 2026
Does data lie to us when it captures the measurable but not the real? Yes, and it tells three lies. It omits, projects and flatters.
Why extreme risk cannot be measured
26 June 2026
Can we measure extreme financial risk? Is financial stability only a question of technology and data? Many seem to think so. I disagree.
Which is better, ES or VaR?
30 November 2024
Almost everyone insists that Expected Shortfall (ES) is superior to Value-at-Risk (VaR). But is that truly the case?
Risk forecasting models are least reliable when needed the most
23 November 2024
When measuring model risk with risk ratios, we find it highest when markets are in turmoil. In other words, model risk is highest, and the risk forecasting models least reliable, when they are needed the most.
The magic of riskometers
10 December 2022
The way financial risk is measured is by a device I have called the riskometer. It is a fantastic thing, plunge it into the bowels of the City of London and out pops a single accurate measurement of risk. Magical. But does it work in practice?
How to manipulate risk forecasts and not get caught
19 November 2022
It is easy to manipulate risk forecasts. If your regulator or compliance officer sets a risk target you don't like, just tell them what they want to hear while continuing doing what you want.
Perceived and actual risk
12 November 2022
Perceived risk is risk predicted by models, and actual risk is the fundamental underlying risk. We measure perceived risk and care about the actual risk. Those two are negatively correlated with interesting consequences.
Misleading measurements and garbage in - garbage out models of systemic risk
23 May 2021
There are many measurements of systemic risk and a huge number of papers depend on those measurements. But is that work of any use? There is an archetypical story from May 1944 where the staff of General Eisenhower called up the Army's meteorological office to ask for the weather forecast for Normandy on June 6. The meteorologists responded by saying, “Any weather forecast a month in the future is meaningless.” The response from the general's staff was: “Yes, we know that, but we need a number for planning purposes.”
Riskometers and their inconsistencies
10 April 2021
Risk measurements are quite inconsistent. Does that matter, and how to interpret the results?
The five principles of correct riskometer use
27 April 2020
It is easy to criticise risk forecasting, but it's rather pointless unless one can come up with proposals. Here are my five principles for the correct use of riskometers.
The problem with Backtesting
25 April 2020
Backtesting is the magical technique that tells us how well a forecast model works. Test the model on history, and we have an objective way to evaluate how good the model is. But does it really work in practice?
Here be dragons
7 October 2017
Medieval mapmakers noted the risk of an unknown kind by “here be dragons”. Attempts at measuring extreme risk should come with a similar warning. Just like the sailors of yesteryear, financial institutions will go into unknown territories and, just like the map makers of the earlier era, modern risk modellers have little to say.
VIX, CISS and all the political uncertainty
3 October 2017
Two widely used indicators of financial risk, the VIX index and the ECB's CISS are at a historical low. The (financial) world must be really safe. However, that doesn't square with all the newspaper headlines screaming political uncertainty. What gives?
Big Banks' Risk Does Not Compute
24 May 2016
A Bloomberg piece that cites our work, Big Banks' Risk Does Not Compute.
Models and regulations and the political leadership
27 February 2016
Why do the regulatory authorities seemingly fall into the category of model believers, if not quite to the view that there must be one true model? Well, it is sort of inevitable the way the regulatory process works.
Why do we rely so much on models when we know they can't be trusted?
26 February 2016
There a lot of evidence that models are less than perfectly reliable. Why then do we rely so much on models in decision-making, and especially financial regulations? Because there are three types of people: Believers in true model, skeptics who accept model risk and nihilistic rejectionists.
Does a true model exist and does it matter?
25 February 2016
When designing models, the underlying assumption is often that the model captures the true data generating process. Does a true model exist? To me, the question is completely irrelevant.
Impact of the recent market turmoil on risk measures
28 August 2015
Last January I looked at how the Swiss FX shock affected the most popular risk measures. Events of the past week give us another interesting test. My daily risk forecast shows the various risk measures for a number of assets, but focus on the SP-500, and the following picture taken from the site today:
Market moves that are supposed to happen every half-decade keep happening
14 May 2015
Bloomberg today had an interesting piece, called Market Moves That Are Supposed to Happen Every Half-Decade Keep Happening. Here is their self-described "terribly simplistic list"
The Danish FX event
9 March 2015
Denmark had a small FX event on March 20, in the context of the Swiss FX shock, it is not much a of an event, but it does reinforce stereotypes.
What do ES and VaR say about the tails
9 February 2015
So, does ES capture tail risk, but VaR not? Therefore the Basel committee is correct, and we all should use ES. Is that true?
What the Swiss FX shock says about risk models
18 January 2015 · VoxEU.org
The Swiss central bank last week abandoned its euro exchange rate ceiling. This column argues that the fallout from the decision demonstrates the inherent weaknesses of the regulator-approved standard risk models used in financial institutions. These models under-forecast risk before the announcement and over-forecast risk after the announcement, getting it wrong in all states of the world.
On the Swiss FX shock
9 January 2015
Just looked again at the what I did on the January 2015 Swiss FX shock, looking at how the various risk measures performed in the days after the event, and also looking at the risk of the inverse FX.
Model risk: Risk measures when models may be wrong
8 June 2014 · VoxEU.org
Risk forecasting is central to financial regulations, risk management, and macroprudential policy. This column raises concerns about the reliance on risk forecasting, since risk forecast models have high levels of model risk - especially when the models are needed the most, during crises. Policymakers should be wary of relying solely on such models. Formal model-risk analysis should be a part of the regulatory design process.
The appropriate use of risk models: Part II
17 June 2011 · VoxEU.org
Financial risk models have been widely criticised for both theoretical and practical failures, especially during the recent financial crisis. In the second of two columns, the authors outline why the shortcomings of risk models matter before making suggestions for how the financial industry and supervisors should use models in practice.
The appropriate use of risk models: Part I
16 June 2011 · VoxEU.org
Risk models are at the heart of the financial sector's self-monitoring as well as supervision by regulators. This column, the first of two, addresses the question of how risk models are misused in practice by practitioners and supervisors alike. This misuse causes risk management to fail when it is most needed.
Risk and crises: How the models failed and are failing
18 February 2011 · VoxEU.org
Financial models are widely blamed for underestimating and thus mispricing risk prior to the crisis. This column analyses how the models failed and questions their prominent use in the post-crisis reform process. It argues that over-relying on market data and statistical forecasting models has the potential to further destabilise the financial system and increase systemic risk.
Financial regulation built on sand: The myth of the riskometer
1 March 2009 · VoxEU.org
Much of today's financial regulation assumes that risk can be accurately measured so that financial engineers, like civil engineers, can design safe products with sophisticated maths informed by historical estimates. But, as the crisis has shown, the laws of finance react to financial engineers' creations, rendering risk calculations invalid. Regulators should rely on simpler methods.
Regulation and financial models: Complexity kills
29 September 2008 · VoxEU.org
Complex financial models and intricate assets structures meant extraordinary profits before the crisis. Markets for structured products became overly inflated as even the banks did not have a clear view of the state of their investments. Given complexity's role in today's mess, future regulation should focus on variables that are easy to measure and hard to manipulate (e.g. leverage ratios).
Blame the models
8 May 2008 · VoxEU.org
In response to financial turmoil, supervisors are demanding more risk calculations. But model-driven mispricing produced the crisis, and risk models don't perform during crisis conditions. The belief that a really complicated statistical model must be right is merely foolish sophistication.